Fics like Haunting You Haunting Me

To Alex, Sara is everything she never thought she’d want and maybe the one person who understands her best. To Sara, Alex is a pile of awkward who turns into a badass in an instant and a steady presence she never thought she'd need. They told themselves and each other it would only be that one night. They lied.

You may also like

1. How Danvers Sisters, and their Family saved the Arrowverse by ijedi (Supergirl (TV 2015), DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV), more)
2. The Misadventures of Alien's Drinks and TimeTravel by TheLionGirl (Supergirl (TV 2015), DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV))
3. Super Legends by SteveM (Supergirl (TV 2015), DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV))
4. Caught off Guard by graywoman (Supergirl (TV 2015), DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV))
5. The Partnership by xHeyIHeardURAWildOnex (DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV))
6. Sweet Girl by TML9115 (DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV))
7. noteworthy by C_AND_B (Supergirl (TV 2015))
8. Blown Away by Artemis_66 (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Arrow (TV 2012), more)
9. Never Let go by Bahama_mama (Supergirl (TV 2015), Grey's Anatomy)
10. Barriers Between by beezyland (DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV), Supergirl (TV 2015))
11. Holiday Wedding Date by beezyland (Supergirl (TV 2015), DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV), more)
12. Heartbeats by Musetotheworld (Supergirl (TV 2015))
13. time's a fickle bitch by C_AND_B (Supergirl (TV 2015))
14. What Do You Desire? by Phoenixcorpp (Supergirl (TV 2015), Lucifer (TV), more)
15. Supergirl Age Play AU by Virginia_Blue (Supergirl (TV 2015))
16. How do you feel about Ohio? by TheReviewess (Arrow (TV 2012), DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV))
17. it’s 9am (and I don’t feel a thing) by LaMaupin (DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV))
18. We Had Our Chance by comebackbehere (Supergirl (TV 2015), Supergirl (TV 2015) RPF, more)
19. there’s magic in your veins (can i have a taste?) by C_AND_B (Supergirl (TV 2015))
20. you had me at pineapple doesn't belong on pizza by C_AND_B (Supergirl (TV 2015))