Fics like Brought Back to the Surface

Two years after Sam lost a shoe in Black Rock, he and Dean are back in town on what's meant to be a routine vampire hunt. They've just finished cleaning up when a voice interrupts them and offers Sam back the shoe in question, and that's how they meet Castiel: eccentric loner, collector of lost objects, and oh, shapeshifter. He's polite, charming, and he makes Dean reconsider everything he's ever thought about monsters and what to do with them.

You may also like

1. Dereliction of Duty by surlybobbies (Supernatural)
2. When Cas Was There by manofbeskar (Supernatural)
3. The Wall by make_your_user_a_name (Supernatural)
4. The Bachelor by blondebadwolf (Supernatural)
5. 25¢ pocket guardian angels by hopelessheathen (Supernatural)
6. the more you love a memory by deancaskiss (Supernatural)
7. A Single Feather by laceymcbain (Supernatural)
8. Sympathy for the Devil by followyourenergy (Supernatural)
9. The Owl Prince by K_K_TiBal (Supernatural)
10. Call my Name by laceymcbain (Supernatural)
11. Games of Skill and Fortune by aeli_kindara (Supernatural)
12. Gimme Shelter (Or I'm Gonna Fade Away) by FagurFiskur (Supernatural)
13. a certain light by flightagain (Supernatural)
14. Carmen Cygni by chevrolangels (Supernatural)
15. the little angel (stay all day in the sun) by rhinestoneangels (Supernatural)
16. Promises I Can't Keep by MalMuses (Supernatural)
17. Splatter by Violetlyvanilla (Supernatural)
18. It's A Long Life to Always Be Longing by superhoney (Supernatural)
19. As You Will by kototyph (Supernatural)
20. Astra et Luna by LoversAntiquities (Supernatural)