Fics like Cast Into Hell

Reader is born into the cult living in the church in Silent Hill. After showing too much interest in the darker aspects of the town's religion, they are cast into the belly of the beast to die at the hands of the Executioner. Contains forced nudity and canon-typical Pyramid Head shenanigans. Takes place in the movieverse but I tried to mix the behaviors of both the movie and games' P Heads. Reader's gender is not specified. Enjoy <3

You may also like

  1. Offering by DarthFucamus (Silent Hill (Video Game Series), Silent Hill (2006), more)
  2. Slasher/Horror Headcanons by SkylarsBlue (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Halloween Movies - All Media Types, more)
  3. Closer by kazahegao (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  4. fox bride (Silent Hill (Video Game Series), Silent Hill f)
  5. Full Circle (and Then Some) by BlueMoonRoses (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  6. Limbo by morbiicore (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  7. Home Sweet Home by Caketastrophe (原神 | Genshin Impact (Video Game), Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  8. Marriage Law Rejection Letters by sakura_lisel (Harry Potter - Fandom, One Piece, more)
  9. One Heartbeat Shared By Two by Lord_Caius (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  10. Get Out Of My Town by smileyfacegauges (Silent Hill, Silent Hill 2 - Fandom, more)
  11. Kinktober 2025 (video game men x reader) ୨ৎ by sinonimgirl (Biohazard | Resident Evil (Gameverse), The Last of Us (Video Games), more)
  12. "Twin Peaks", an erotic choose-your-own-adventure parody of Silent Hill by Dachimotsu (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  13. Courageous Heart by ZombBean (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  14. Surviving the Game by Blot_Squisher (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Scream (Movies), more)
  15. I Love You, Do You Love Me? Lets Set Our House On Fire by angel_trap (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Halloween Movies - All Media Types, more)
  16. Hero's Soul Mate by Solaris26Gem (対魔忍アサギ | Taimanin Asagi (Anime), 対魔忍ユキカゼ | Taimanin Yukikaze (Anime), more)
  17. Over the Silent Hills, You'll Find Self Love. by Medieval (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  18. Tumblr Requests by Mara_xx217 (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), Dead by Daylight (Video Game), more)
  19. Here Today, Gone Tomorrow by AnAttemptAtHumor (Silent Hill (Video Game Series))
  20. Rewarding The Guiltless by Semi_Weird_Shipper (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Silent Hill (2006))