Fics like Dearly beloved

Lena isn't surprised by neighbors knocking on her door to ask if she can spare a cup of sugar or a couple of batteries. What she doesn't expect, however, is an impromptu proposal from her always-borrowing-sugar neighbor whom she barely knows. As if that wasn't crazy enough yet, she finds herself falling for said neighbor.

You may also like

1. that's what (girl)friends are for by C_AND_B (Supergirl (TV 2015))
2. What Do You Mean You're Not Actually in this Class? by cantdrawshaw (Supergirl (TV 2015))
3. By Sun and Candle Light by Gotta_Start_Somewhere (Supergirl (TV 2015))
4. Oblivious by BiJane (Supergirl (TV 2015))
5. Intimate Strangers by ThornedRose44 (Supergirl (TV 2015))
6. Restraint by ThisWriterD (Supergirl (TV 2015))
7. Something Just Like This by Helpbutton95 (Supergirl (TV 2015))
8. what's your town called again? by C_AND_B (Supergirl (TV 2015))
9. asking polite with a gun in your hand by lostariels (Supergirl (TV 2015))
10. Would You Catch Me If I Fall For You ('Cause I'm falling) by Khrat9 (Supergirl (TV 2015))
11. Something Borrowed by janewithawhy (Supergirl (TV 2015))
12. Ends of the Earth by ThornedRose44 (Supergirl (TV 2015))
13. One And The Same by acoolusername (Supergirl (TV 2015))
14. Five Years by acoolusername (Supergirl (TV 2015))
15. muddle my heart (then add a dash of lime) by C_AND_B (Supergirl (TV 2015))
16. don't go slow 'cause you're gonna be someone by robie (Supergirl (TV 2015))
17. but then, my homework was never quite like this by Jazzfordshire (Supergirl (TV 2015))
18. around the world in three kisses by Jazzfordshire (Supergirl (TV 2015))
19. please don't ever become a stranger by pirateygoodness (Supergirl (TV 2015))
20. All In by MyCatIsMyEditor (Supergirl (TV 2015))