Fics like We’re Butter Off Together

Set immediately after the Season Five episode “The End” this canon-divergent story begins with Dean and Sam heading to the Wisconsin State Fair to check out a butter sculpture of an angel that sounds awfully similar to Castiel. Sure enough, when they arrive the incomplete sculpture looks a lot like Cas - enough so that the Winchesters call in the angel himself to help investigate it. Castiel, upon arrival, is mistaken as Dean’s partner - as in “life partner” - and they’re forced to share a room at a local B&B during the investigation. When Cas falls prey to the dark powers at work, Dean must confront his feelings in order to save Castiel.

You may also like

  1. a new life (just a better place to die) by The_Bookkeeper (Supernatural)
  2. Angel of Vengeance by bubblewrapstargirl (Supernatural)
  3. Put up your Dukes by saltyfeathers (Supernatural)
  4. Under My Skin by whichstiel (Supernatural)
  5. Greatest Love of All by teacass (Supernatural)
  6. The Tunnel of Love by xylodemon (Supernatural)
  7. Suck It, Judy Garland by GlitterDwarf, midrashic (Supernatural)
  8. Delilah by nephilisms (Supernatural)
  9. Fake It ‘Til You Make It by Nepenthene (Supernatural)
  10. Have You Heard About The Winchesters? by agirlcalledbauki (Supernatural)
  11. So, That's How it Starts by por_queeee (Supernatural)
  12. Filling the Empty by iamindeeddistressed (Supernatural)
  13. Long Distances by executionersong (Supernatural)
  14. Staring You in the Face by GatesKeeper (Supernatural)
  15. Waveform Frequency by LeverDrift (Supernatural)
  16. Beautiful Mess by LoversAntiquities (Supernatural)
  17. The Least Bad Option by thestoryinsideme (Supernatural)
  18. Waiting for More by perilously (Supernatural)
  19. Not Quite Perfect by bumblewyn (Supernatural)
  20. Ache by HigherMagic (Supernatural)