Fics like Let the Punishment Fit the Crime

"I want you to keep track of how many puns you make tonight," Cas said, right before they left to go to their very own engagement party. What could possibly go wrong?

You may also like

1. A Little Tied Up by Dangerousnotbroken (Supernatural)
2. St. Mary's School for Boys by relucant (Supernatural)
3. Love Your Heat by orphan_account (Supernatural)
4. Stills of Silk and Rope by hollyblue2 (Supernatural)
5. F*cking Fairies by darkforetold (Supernatural)
6. Dirty by littleartemis (Supernatural)
7. Long Exposure by saltnhalo (Supernatural)
8. Don't Ever Change by SailorChibi (Supernatural)
9. This Burning Inside by xxenjoy (Supernatural)
10. Touchstone by tempusborealis (Supernatural)
11. The Bodyguard by xxenjoy (Supernatural)
12. Swelter by Dangerousnotbroken (Supernatural)
13. Command Me to Be Well by PorcupineGirl (Supernatural)
14. 3000 Miles, Give Or Take by Dangerousnotbroken (Supernatural)
15. Suffer Well by xxenjoy (Supernatural)
16. Topics Under Review by relucant (Supernatural)
17. Whenever I'm Alone With You by Casloveshisfreckles (Supernatural)
18. Toy Cars by bdxjimin (Supernatural)
19. Somebody to Love by MashiarasDream, tinnydandelion (Supernatural)
20. My Whole Existence Is Flawed by Duckyboos (Supernatural)